Teams Sherfane Rutherford played for

ODIWest Indies (2023/24)
International Twenty20West Indies (2018/19-2023/24)
Main FCGuyana (2016/17-2018/19)
Main ListAGuyana (2017/18-2023/24)
Main Twenty20Guyana Amazon Warriors (2018-2020)
 Delhi Capitals (2019)
 Sylhet Thunder (2019/20)
 Karachi Kings (2020/21)
 Peshawar Zalmi (2020/21-2021/22)
 St Kitts and Nevis Patriots (2021-2023)
 Colombo Stars (2021/22)
 Royal Challengers Bangalore (2022)
 Quetta Gladiators (2023/24)
Other ListAWest Indies A (2019)
 West Indies (2023/24)
Other Twenty20West Indies (2018/19-2023/24)
 Desert Vipers (2023/24)
Indian Premier LeagueDelhi Capitals (2019)
 Royal Challengers Bangalore (2022)
Bangladesh Premier LeagueSylhet Thunder (2019/20)
Caribbean Premier LeagueGuyana Amazon Warriors (2018-2020)
 St Kitts and Nevis Patriots (2021-2023)
Pakistan Super LeagueKarachi Kings (2020/21)
 Peshawar Zalmi (2020/21-2021/22)
 Quetta Gladiators (2023/24)
Lanka Premier LeagueColombo Stars (2021/22)
West Indies CompetitionGuyana (2016/17-2018/19)
MiscellaneousGuyana Under-17s (2013-2014)
 Demerara Under-19s (2014)
 Demerara Under-17s (2014)
 Guyana Under-19s (2015-2016)
 West Indies B (2018)
 Bengal Tigers (2018/19)
 Delhi Bulls (2019/20-2021/22)
 St Kitts and Nevis Patriots (2022)
 Northern Warriors (2022/23)
 Desert Vipers (2022/23)
 Montreal Tigers (2023)